Strength training and cardio do different jobs. Cardio burns more calories per session and, in a Duke University trial, reduced more body fat. Strength training builds and protects muscle, which supports resting metabolism and blood sugar control. For metabolism and health, the best plan includes both.
Key takeaways
- In an 8-month trial, aerobic training reduced fat mass more than resistance training.
- Resistance training increased lean mass. Aerobic training alone did not.
- Resistance training raises resting metabolic rate modestly. Aerobic training alone shows no clear effect.
- Guidelines recommend 150 minutes of moderate cardio, or 75 minutes of vigorous cardio, plus two strength sessions a week.
Which is better for your goal?
| Main goal | Prioritize | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Losing body fat | Cardio, plus two strength sessions | Cardio burns more per session; strength work protects muscle while you lose weight |
| Building muscle and strength | Strength training | Only resistance training increased lean mass in the Duke trial |
| Lower visceral (deep belly) fat | Cardio | Aerobic training reduces visceral fat in trials that measured it by scan |
| Blood sugar control | Both | Both make muscles more sensitive to insulin |
| Healthy aging | Strength and balance, plus daily walking | Muscle loss speeds up with age if muscles are not used |
Which burns more fat, strength training or cardio?
In the one trial that compared them head to head over months, cardio burned more fat. The STRRIDE AT/RT trial at Duke University assigned 119 sedentary adults with overweight or obesity to one of three programs for eight months: aerobic training (about 12 miles a week of jogging-equivalent exercise), resistance training (three days a week, eight exercises, three sets), or both.
| Group | Body weight and fat mass | Lean mass | Time per week |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aerobic | Reduced significantly | Little change | About 2¼ hours |
| Resistance | No significant fat loss | Increased | About 3 hours |
| Both | Reduced, similar to aerobic alone | Increased | About 5 hours |
The authors concluded that, for reducing fat and body mass, aerobic training was the more time-efficient choice, and that resistance training was needed to increase lean mass.
What does cardio do for metabolism?
Cardio mainly raises the calories you burn while you do it and improves insulin sensitivity.
- Burns more during the session. Per minute, steady running burns far more energy than a typical weight-training session.
- Reduces visceral fat, the deep abdominal fat linked with metabolic disease. A meta-analysis of trials that measured it by CT or MRI found that aerobic exercise reduced it, while resistance training alone did not show a significant effect.
- Makes muscles more sensitive to insulin in the hours and days after each session.
- Improves heart and lung fitness.
What does strength training do for metabolism?
Strength training builds the muscle that supports resting energy use and blood sugar control.
- Builds and keeps muscle. This matters most during weight loss and with age, when muscle is otherwise lost.
- Raises resting metabolic rate modestly. A meta-analysis found an increase of about 100 kcal a day with resistance training compared with controls, and no clear increase with aerobic exercise alone.
- Improves glucose handling. More muscle means more room to store the glucose from a meal.
- Protects bones and physical function.
See does building muscle increase metabolism? for the numbers.
Does the afterburn favor weights or HIIT?
Harder and longer cardio sessions produce a larger afterburn, but even then it adds only 6 to 15 percent to the energy cost of the workout. Evidence for weight training is too limited to compare. The afterburn should not decide your choice. See the afterburn effect.
How much exercise do you need for weight management?
A position stand from the American College of Sports Medicine summarizes the dose-response:
- 150 to 250 minutes a week of moderate activity helps prevent weight gain and produces modest weight loss.
- More than 250 minutes a week is associated with clinically significant weight loss.
- Resistance training does not add much to weight loss by itself, but it increases fat-free mass and improves health risks.
Exercise without changes in diet usually produces less weight loss than people expect. See does exercise burn as many calories as you think?
How do you combine strength training and cardio in one week?
A balanced week
- Monday: full-body strength, 30–45 minutes
- Tuesday: brisk walk or cycle, 30–40 minutes
- Wednesday: brisk walk, 30 minutes
- Thursday: full-body strength, 30–45 minutes
- Friday: cardio with some harder intervals, 20–30 minutes
- Saturday: longer walk, hike or sport, 45–60 minutes
- Sunday: rest
If you have only about three hours a week
Two 30-minute strength sessions plus 150 minutes of brisk walking meets the guidelines in about 3½ hours. With vigorous cardio, such as running, 75 minutes is enough, so the total drops to about 2¼ hours.
If your main goal is fat loss
Keep the two strength sessions to protect muscle, and add cardio and daily steps for energy expenditure.
If your main goal is healthy aging
Prioritize strength and balance work, and keep walking daily.
Which should come first in a session?
Do first whatever matters most to you, since you will be freshest for it. For general fitness, the order makes little difference.
Safety
Talk to a health professional first if you have heart disease, blood pressure that is not under control, joint pain, or have been inactive for months, and increase the load slowly.
Frequently asked questions
How many days a week should I do strength training and cardio?
The CDC recommends muscle-strengthening activity on at least two days a week and cardio spread across most days, adding up to 150 minutes of moderate or 75 minutes of vigorous activity.
Will cardio burn my muscle?
Not at normal amounts, especially if you also do strength work and eat enough protein.
Can I lose fat with weights alone?
Yes, combined with a suitable diet. You will lose it more slowly than with added cardio.
Does walking count as cardio?
Brisk walking counts as moderate-intensity aerobic activity. See walking and metabolism.
Sources
- Willis LH, et al. Effects of aerobic and/or resistance training on body mass and fat mass in overweight or obese adults. J Appl Physiol (1985). 2012.
- Ismail I, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect of aerobic vs. resistance exercise training on visceral fat. Obes Rev. 2012.
- MacKenzie-Shalders K, et al. The effect of exercise interventions on resting metabolic rate: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Sports Sci. 2020.
- Donnelly JE, et al. American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. Appropriate physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss and prevention of weight regain for adults. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2009.
- LaForgia J, et al. Effects of exercise intensity and duration on the excess post-exercise oxygen consumption. J Sports Sci. 2006.
- CDC. Adult Activity: An Overview.
Featured photo: Drazen Zigic / Freepik
